On the outside looking in things seem idyllic in the small town of Braden, Pennsylvania. High school football is king, crime is low, people are friendly, and The Kitchen restaurant is the go to place for gossip and socializing.
Look a little deeper, however, and you’ll find secrets and lies festering. And violence.
Eleven years ago Carol, a well-liked young waitress, was brutally murdered. The murder occurred right around the time a man named Sean, husband of The Kitchen’s owner Risa, disappeared without a trace. Left to pick up the pieces of her life, Risa married Alan, a local politician who took her son, Kevin, under his wing as his own.
Sean was eventually declared dead legally, Kevin has grown into a confident young football star, and Alan is running for state office. Life is good. Until Sean shows up as jarringly out of the blue as he disappeared, claiming the man who was convicted of Carol’s murder is actually innocent. Sean knows this, he insists, because he was the one who killed her.
Now secrets long buried are being unearthed, a small town closes ranks, politics rears its ugly head, and Risa must figure out which life is real…the one she has now, or the one she thought was as dead and buried as Carol.